M&M

Monasticism and martyrdom.  The situation in which the Trappist monks in Algeria found themselves was a complicated one. The monastery had a positive relationship with the village it was located in, with harmony between Christians and Muslims, but faced a threat of terror from outside extremists. A decision had to be made: stay, and help the city, or leave and be safe. In his Last Testament, de Cherge referred to martyrdom as “grace”, yet he “could not desire such a death”. To desire martyrdom is to contradict what it means to be a martyr. A martyr is chosen by God, and by remaining in the city to be with the people who lived there, to help the people as much as possible, to do as God would have wanted, raised the eligibility of the monks to be chosen as martyrs. It almost seems intuitive, yet crass, that monks would be the most willing to become martyrs because of the fact that they have already made the decision to give up their traditional lives for God (to grow closer to communion with Him, to strengthen the gaze with Him). However, as mentioned by de Cherge, there is conflict in this martyrdom. To be killed by one that you love is difficult. Also, in reference to the analogy calling Islam and Algeria the soul and the body, martyrdom at the hands of Islamic fundamentalists would only further separate the body and the soul of the people. The decision upon which the entire movie Of Gods and Men hinges, to stay or to leave, is of utmost moral importance. To serve all of the children of God is a goal reflected in the quotation at the beginning of the movie from the Book of Psalms, Psalm 82:6–7: “I have said, Ye are gods; and all of you are children of the most High. But ye shall die like men, and fall like one of the princes.” From this perspective, it becomes clear that there is a parallel between the monks and Jesus. Jesus, martyred by the Jews, and the monks, martyred by fundamental Muslims, were both of God and of man, who served mankind and proved the divinity of God’s creation.

Many Carps

The martyrdom of Polycarp parallels strongly to the passion of Jesus Christ. Both narratives contain a betrayal of the martyr, and truly went on to become one with the Father our creator in the process of their deaths. They knew what their fates must have been before they happened, and did not attempt to change this and accepting their unjust persecution. Both were devout to God, not straying from his path even to avoid death. This imitation is important because the death or murder of the elect comes with consequences for the witnesses to it. They are remembered and spoken of by both believer and heathen, and their devotion to the Lord is an example for all. The unique circumstances of their deaths have led each to both heaven and to legend. They both have taught the word of the Lord, and in their martyrdom, the death of Christ and in one of his believers viewed as parallels, the Word has been substantiated and spread throughout the world.

The Humanity of Christ

It is difficult to fully comprehend that Jesus Christ is both God and man. In chapter eight of the Gospel of John, Christ himself claims to be a man, and always refers to God the Creator as his Father, which seems to indicate that they are separate entities. However, such an Arian belief has evidence contradicting it in the Bible as well as claims from the Creed of Nicea and the Creed of Chalcedon. Christ, through his miracles, proves his divinity without a doubt. Cyril of Alexandria argues that Christ as he was born, Christ from the womb is not in himself God, but rather that God was within Christ. Nestorius argues as well that Christ was an instrument of God, but still worships him as undivided from the Creator. It seems to be that Christ, as a man born of flesh as mentioned in John 3:6, became one with God and acted as a person with divine nature.

Athanasius and Arius

Arius made the claim that “The Son has a beginning, but God is without beginning”, and this statement, that Jesus Christ is the Son and therefore distinct and subordinate from God the Father, is the basis of Arianism. Athanasius argues against this idea in Orations Against the Arians, making the claim that that questions proposed by the Arians are the same questions posed by the Jews in the time of Christ, which ultimately led to His death. The argument of Athanasius is simple: the Arians misinterpreted the texts that they used as evidence against the oneness of the Father and the Son. The Lord had to become, not appear to be, human, to bear our sins for our sake. The Creed of Nicea, by siding with Athanasius, does not add to scripture, but reinforces it. The arguments made all use scripture as evidence of their claims. Since scripture itself is used to argue, the Creed adds nothing to it, but rather clarifies.

Snite Museum Extra Credit

The Nativity is a sixteenth century painting by Jacopo Bassano da Ponte of Italy. This Thursday, a group of us visited the Snite Museum and engaged in an open discussion of the piece. We spent a lot of time analyzing the work, bringing up topics such as the overall dark theme of the painting, the presence of the animals, and the anachronistic, armored soldier who appears to be from da Ponts’s time leaning in on the left side of the painting. One aspect we found to be peculiar was the fact that even though the son of God was just born, the King of Kings, the focus of the lighting was on Mary. Odd. What is also odd is the fact that despite the miracle that had just occurred, nobody seemed to be joyous. The only indication that anything important of divine is occurring, despite the fact that so many are leaning in to see the infant, is the presence of the angels, but that is only in the top half of the painting. A small mark of symbolism can be found at the animal nearest to Jesus: a lamb. This is one of the more obvious foreshadowings of the both this painting and history. Many questions remain unanswered: who are all of these people around Jesus? Why is the man with the donkey so far in the shadow he is invisible until pointed out to the observer? Why is nobody happy? What purpose does the sixteenth century soldier serve to the overall painting? What is Jacopo’s message?

Perpetua

It is difficult to willfully remain in prison, to reject the will of one’s father and to watch him beaten by the guards of the empire in the prisoner’s dock as a result of your direct disobedience to him, to lose your baby, and to remain condemned to death when you can easily be free and live with just a small lie. A great act of faith is required to do what Perpetua and many of the other martyrs did. In doing so, they not only professed, but proved their love and devotion to Christ. They were led to the ampitheatre of their death with joy rather than fear. I would hope to act in the way Perpetua did because not only did she show unflinching, unquestioned devotion, but she was extraordinarily strong in her resolve in regards to how she was to be shuffled off of this mortal coil. She talked backed to both the guards and the crowd. Such bravery is to be admired, and hopefully repeated by others.

The Zeal of Martyrdom: A Case Against Gnostic Belief

The reading “Letters of the Church of Vienne and Lyon” implicitly does away with the Gnostic claim the the God of the Old Testament is separate from the God of the New Testament with the example of Christian prisoners in second century Rome. These Christian prisoners had nothing to gain from being jailed and tortured in the name of Christ. Despite being tortured twice as harshly as those convicted as murderers and villains, those who professed their love of Christ felt Christ’s love right back, and found comfort in times of tribulation. However, the text implies two important points: first, based on the syntax of the letters, the feeling of mercy derives from Christ the man, and not from God, which can imply that Christ and God serve two distinct purposes, and the mercy found in the New Testament does not stem from God directly; second, and most importantly, the Christians were still tortured terribly, and many died, which indicates that the New Testament God may not be quite as merciful as some may believe, so he is the same God as the Old Testament one.

Marcion/Farkasfalvy

According to Marcion, there is a sharp distinction between the good, just God and Christ figures, and the figure that is the Creator. Christ acts as a forgiving and loving individual, while the Creator is a more cruel, harsh figure; this distinction implies that the God of the Old Testament is not the same as the God of the New Testament. In reference to tradition, and in the words of Farkasfalvy, the new apostolic writings are meant to add to the words of the Old Testament, not contradict it. The rule of faith, in knowing that the Creator and Christ are both the same God, as with the canonical principle, state that Christians, both from Jewish and Gentile backgrounds, would need to take into account the words from both the times before Christ and after.

Galatians

The law has been a popular subject of conversation throughout both the Old and New Testaments. In determining how a person should live, in a way that would best serve the Lord, the Law, and more specifically the Ten Commandments given to Moses at Mount Sinai, has been the basic guideline of living. Jesus, in Matthew 5:17, reinforces this idea, but in his letter to the Galatians, Paul says otherwise, stating that the word of Jesus Christ should be the guide of man. Really, neither of these statements are incorrect. While it is impossible to follow the law perfectly, it is used to guide mankind to the word of Jesus. Both are directly the word of God. The law is a tool to be used by man in order to properly understand and utilize the word of Jesus Christ.

The Gospel of Mark

Right from the beginning, Jesus Christ is shown to be a forgiving, selfless, giving man. He spends his time healing the sick, spreading the word of God, eating with sinners. He is also depicted as a wise teacher, using parables and drawing large crowds (even when he has to teach in nontraditional places) who are impressed with his teachings.

One surprising aspect of the Gospel of Mark is the writing style. It begins with a series of actions, one right after another with little context or detail. As the history develops, there is more insight given into the actions of Jesus. Rich metaphors such as in chapter two, when discussing mixing the old and the new, using clothes and wine skin, as well as allusions to specific actions of the past, particularly those of David, were unexpected to me. The other surprising aspect is the density of miracles. Jesus is entirely selfless; he spends all of his time preaching, performing miracles, feeding the hungry, and blessing those in need. It is not surprising that he does such actions, it is only surprising how frequently this is done. Jesus proves that he is the messiah, the true son of God by dedicating and giving his life to serve humanity.